Monday, November 11, 2013

With United Methodist bishop Sally Dyck

Day 6: Justice

Photo by Joanna Linden-Montes/WCC
The assembly engaged in significant reflection on one of the stated themes of the gathering—justice. In the day’s thematic plenary, we were challenged and inspired to engage in God’s work of justice in the world. We heard about greed and poverty, war, HIV/AIDS, and human rights and we were reminded that the God of life calls us to sharing in God’s justice. Malaysian journalist and Geneva-based South Center executive director told us “do not give charity but tackle the sinful structures that give rise to poverty.” South African pastor and activist Phumzile Mabizela called us to action, stating that our prayers must accompany our work for justice. She said “prayer on its own will not bring us justice"

During the plenary was deeply moved by one young person’s narrative. Shyreen Mvula, a 19 year old woman from Malawi, shared her story about living as HIV positive. She had questions about her life and her future, the same questions that all young people ask. Yet her disease cast a cloud over her future. Was she going to have children? Would her children have HIV/AIDS? Mvula spoke profound words that morning: “HIV is not a punishment from God. It is just a disease, so let's fight this disease.” Her statement reminded us that the church has too often condemned and not loved those with HIV/AIDS.

The World Council of Churches has facilitated God’s work of justice for decades. Through public statements, joint advocacy, and information-sharing, the WCC is critical for organizing ecumenical responses and action on justice. The World Council of Churches has the ability to transcend national, ethnic, and denominational boundaries and call member churches and the world to enact God’s justice in the world. The WCC enables United Methodists to work ecumenically on issues of justice and gives entry to global organizations like the United Nations.

During the General Assembly, we are considering statements on indigenous people, rights of religious minorities, and stateless persons. Click here to read the statements. 


Day 6 highlights—Bible study based on the story of Jezebel and Naboth, justice thematic plenary, reports on public issues and assembly message

United Methodist missionaries and mission staff participate in 10th General Assembly

Over 2,500 participants from nearly 345 denominations gathered in Busan, Korea, for the 10th General Assembly of the World Council of Churches. The once every 7 year meeting is a time of prayer, Bible study, and reflection for church leaders, theologians, seminaries, and laity. Additionally, the General Assembly sets the overall programmatic and financial policies for the World Council of Churches. The theme of the assembly was ‘God of life, lead us to justice and peace.’

GBGM staff and missionaries participated in every aspect of the General Assembly. The Rev. Matthew A. Laferty, missionary in Russia, was an official representative of The United Methodist Church and served as a General Assembly delegate. Laferty also was a member of the assembly finance committee. Dr. Andrew Donaldson, GBGM missionary serving as coopted WCC staff in the area of music and worship, was integral in the design of prayer services and provided musical leadership during the assembly. Mission intern Annie Solis Escalante is serving in the WCC health and healing program in Geneva and assisted in facilitating the assembly in Busan.

Thomas Kemper, Denise Honeycutt, and Jorge Dominguez represented the General Board of Global Ministries to the General Assembly. GBGM is a recognized by the World Council of Churches as a specialized agency engaged in diaconal and international work. Dominguez also facilitated one of the twenty-one ecumenical conversations. Young adult missionary services executive Elizabeth Lee and GBGM director and UMW national president Yvotte Richards also took part in the assembly.

Throughout the ten-day conference many missionaries, former missionaries, and mission partners attended the parts of proceedings, lead workshops, and staffed exhibits and information booths.


During the assembly an entire day was dedicated to mission and the mission document Together Toward Life (TTL). The new document is a recently approved mission theology statement by the WCC World Mission and Evangelism Commission, the first such statement in 30 years.  Together Toward Life affirms God’s invitation to us to celebrate life and to transform evil forces as well as reminds us that we are messengers of Jesus Christ. The document calls us to mission on the margins, moving the church to ministry with people living on the fringes of our society. TTL also embraces the reality that mission engagement occurs in multi-cultural contexts. From the assembly theme on justice and peace, TTL intentionally links mission and justice; mission must be justice.

Thursday, November 7, 2013

Day 4: Mission Together

Each day of the General Assembly a theme is interlaced throughout the Bible study, daily thematic plenary session, and prayer services. On Monday I was anxious for the assembly theme: mission. As a United Methodist missionary serving through the United Methodist mission agency (the General Board of Global Ministries) the ‘mission’ theme seemed particularly relevant to my work in Moscow.

The new WCC mission document—Together Toward Life—was the centerpiece of the day. An important function of the World Council of Churches is to bring member churches toward a common vision of Christian faith as we seek unity in Christ. In the 21st century it is critical that Christians articulate a shared understanding of mission so we maximize our work and reach. Especially for local churches, TTL offers a profound alternative to outdated models of mission.

Together Toward Life affirms God’s invitation to us to celebrate life and to transform evil forces as well as reminds us that we are messengers of Jesus Christ. The document calls us to mission on the margins, moving the church to ministry with people living on the fringes of our society. TTL also embraces the reality that mission engagement occurs in multi-cultural contexts. From the assembly theme on justice and peace, TTL intentionally links mission and justice; mission must be justice.

Click here to view Together Toward Life online.


Day 4 Highlights: Plenary session on Mission and Together Toward Life, WCC central committee nominations, ecumenical conversations on mission

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Nobel laureate Leymah Gwobee to global church leaders

Church leaders who remain silent in the face of injustice might as well be firing a gun and shooting people

Feeling Warm and Cool about the WCC General Assembly

Response to the Fourth Report of the Nominations Committee (NC 04) Recommendation B—Youth Advisory Delegates

As a general assembly delegate and a youth, I shared with a delegation colleague my frustration about the lack of representation of youth on the central committee. He wrote back and said

I experienced a similar situation when I was a youth delegate in 1991 [in Canberra]. At that assembly all of the youth delegates decided to vote against the nominating committee report openly and a group of about 50 of us youth delegates, participants and stewards staged a protest, carrying a tall banner and balloons across the plenary, blocking the view of the moderating table with words saying something like: you are not seeing the youth of the ecumenical movement.

It is clear that the nominations committee is encumbered by an archaic process that continues to marginalized women, young people, laity, indigenous persons, and persons with disabilities.  We cannot pretend that a gentle proposal like youth advisory delegates will create radical transformation desperately needed for the WCC. Rather youth must demand a place at the table with voice and vote through utilizing the flawed substitution nomination process. The proposal for youth advisory delegates does not adequately address the issue of youth representation and sets a dangerous precedent. Such a proposal absolves the assembly from initiating serious and substantial change. Some of my fellow youth delegates are so hungry for bread that they will accept half a loaf.


Many youth delegates engaged in a consensus process to develop proposals in response to the nominations report. Our desire to find a common way forward rendered it impossible for us to effectively act since we are deeply divided on our reaction and strategy. While some youth delegates sought the certainty of youth advisory delegates, I encouraged many youth delegates to join together and offer substitute nominations. I lament that our (and my) consensus process delivered us impotent. I do not support the committee’s recommendation and ‘go on record’ to state my objections.

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Karamaga André from the All Africa Council of Churches bringing greetings

My Reaction to WCC Nominations Report

The United Methodist Church is a historic and strong supporter—both morally and financially—of the World Council of Churches. We continue to support the WCC through coopted staff, participation in specialized ministries, and a substantial annual membership contribution.  I am quite distressed by the nominations report. Our confessional family (the Methodist confessional family) has experienced a significant reduction of central committee seats by 50%. My member church—The United Methodist Church—has for many years had 5 seats on the central committee. In this report we have only been allocated 2 seats for the next cycle. Our confessional family was not consulted on these significant reductions nor was my member church. Such changes will render it difficult if not impossible for us to return back to our communion leadership and advocate for substantial support of the World Council of Churches.

We are committed to the World Council of Churches, but the World Council of Churches must be committed to us.

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Dinner with the Mayor of Busan


Day 2: WCC Tries to Build Consensus

In the youth pre-assembly in the two days preceding the General Assembly I heard that the World Council of Churches (WCC) works on a consensus model. My initial thought was that all churches work on a consensus model. Certainly in our deliberations as United Methodists we discern the Holy Spirit’s guidance and act to bring people together in decision-making. Admittedly we have failed miserably at times, nevertheless our intention remains. Isn’t consensus at the heart of our theology of ‘holy conferencing’?

On the second day of the General Assembly’s proceedings, I now have a new appreciation and understanding of consensus. In the past decade, the World Council of Churches has moved from a majority rules (50% + 1 vote) to a truly all-people-agree consensus model. We were reminded today that consensus is not about winning or losing but seeking God’s will. We are to ask ourselves and each other: what is God saying to us as the World Council of Churches. In the WCC consensus model we do not ‘vote’ per se but express with colored indicator cards our ‘warmth’ (orange card) or ‘coolneess’ (blue card) toward proposals and delegates’ statements. When blue cards are displayed, members are asked to share their hesitation with the proposal and the moderator seeks to find a mutual way forward.

Today I was challenged to think about what it means to be a diverse church seeking unity in Jesus Christ. The old models of ‘majority rule’ decision-making facilitate business quicker but fail to build a common way forward. Can we be a church together if half of us do not support the majority position? The WCC consensus model severely restricts the amount of work that can be transacted; consensus requires significant time for listening and dialoguing between the member churches. Yet the consensus model insures the broadest support and implementation possible. If we are to seek unity in Christ, we must utilize fresh paradigms to be the church especially in how we work.

In the coming days we will be approving two major documents on theology of church (ecclesiology) and mission in the 21st century (missiology) as well as setting the policies, priorities, and goals of the World Council of Churches for the next 8 years.

Highlights from Day 2: Greeting by Republic of Korea Prime Minister Church Hongwon, presentation by Asian churches about the joys and challenges across the region, ecumenical conversations on various issues related to the assembly theme, Bible study on gender justice from Genesis 2, regional meetings for member churches.