Sunday, November 3, 2013

Day 2: WCC Tries to Build Consensus

In the youth pre-assembly in the two days preceding the General Assembly I heard that the World Council of Churches (WCC) works on a consensus model. My initial thought was that all churches work on a consensus model. Certainly in our deliberations as United Methodists we discern the Holy Spirit’s guidance and act to bring people together in decision-making. Admittedly we have failed miserably at times, nevertheless our intention remains. Isn’t consensus at the heart of our theology of ‘holy conferencing’?

On the second day of the General Assembly’s proceedings, I now have a new appreciation and understanding of consensus. In the past decade, the World Council of Churches has moved from a majority rules (50% + 1 vote) to a truly all-people-agree consensus model. We were reminded today that consensus is not about winning or losing but seeking God’s will. We are to ask ourselves and each other: what is God saying to us as the World Council of Churches. In the WCC consensus model we do not ‘vote’ per se but express with colored indicator cards our ‘warmth’ (orange card) or ‘coolneess’ (blue card) toward proposals and delegates’ statements. When blue cards are displayed, members are asked to share their hesitation with the proposal and the moderator seeks to find a mutual way forward.

Today I was challenged to think about what it means to be a diverse church seeking unity in Jesus Christ. The old models of ‘majority rule’ decision-making facilitate business quicker but fail to build a common way forward. Can we be a church together if half of us do not support the majority position? The WCC consensus model severely restricts the amount of work that can be transacted; consensus requires significant time for listening and dialoguing between the member churches. Yet the consensus model insures the broadest support and implementation possible. If we are to seek unity in Christ, we must utilize fresh paradigms to be the church especially in how we work.

In the coming days we will be approving two major documents on theology of church (ecclesiology) and mission in the 21st century (missiology) as well as setting the policies, priorities, and goals of the World Council of Churches for the next 8 years.

Highlights from Day 2: Greeting by Republic of Korea Prime Minister Church Hongwon, presentation by Asian churches about the joys and challenges across the region, ecumenical conversations on various issues related to the assembly theme, Bible study on gender justice from Genesis 2, regional meetings for member churches.

No comments:

Post a Comment