Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Response to the Fourth Report of the Nominations Committee (NC 04) Recommendation B—Youth Advisory Delegates

As a general assembly delegate and a youth, I shared with a delegation colleague my frustration about the lack of representation of youth on the central committee. He wrote back and said

I experienced a similar situation when I was a youth delegate in 1991 [in Canberra]. At that assembly all of the youth delegates decided to vote against the nominating committee report openly and a group of about 50 of us youth delegates, participants and stewards staged a protest, carrying a tall banner and balloons across the plenary, blocking the view of the moderating table with words saying something like: you are not seeing the youth of the ecumenical movement.

It is clear that the nominations committee is encumbered by an archaic process that continues to marginalized women, young people, laity, indigenous persons, and persons with disabilities.  We cannot pretend that a gentle proposal like youth advisory delegates will create radical transformation desperately needed for the WCC. Rather youth must demand a place at the table with voice and vote through utilizing the flawed substitution nomination process. The proposal for youth advisory delegates does not adequately address the issue of youth representation and sets a dangerous precedent. Such a proposal absolves the assembly from initiating serious and substantial change. Some of my fellow youth delegates are so hungry for bread that they will accept half a loaf.


Many youth delegates engaged in a consensus process to develop proposals in response to the nominations report. Our desire to find a common way forward rendered it impossible for us to effectively act since we are deeply divided on our reaction and strategy. While some youth delegates sought the certainty of youth advisory delegates, I encouraged many youth delegates to join together and offer substitute nominations. I lament that our (and my) consensus process delivered us impotent. I do not support the committee’s recommendation and ‘go on record’ to state my objections.

No comments:

Post a Comment